Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica | Puella Magi Madoka Magica Music Collection [MP3]  

So here I thought: "Why not try my hand at offering a missing music collection...?"
Thus this torrent was born. I tried to follow the guidelines and rules as much as possible.
Still, there are a few problems/questions:
1. Should I convert the one .bmp to a different format?
2. The packaged Limited Edition of the ED disc contained the one missing song, thus the catalog ID isn't really correct. Should I take it out and split it off into a different folder for the anime edition of the disc?

good one to offer too...
1) yes, you should convert the bmp to a different format.  Your offer wont be accepted if it has bmp files in it.  Either  png or jpg like the rest should work fine, its really up to you (i usually just convert bmp to png to preserve quality, but since everything else is in jpg it might just be better to be consistent)
2) You need to take a look at the ending single.  there were two editions released, with different track lists (one with 'snow is falling' and one with 'magia (magic mix)', you should prob include both albums (even though its a little redundant).  You can take a look at the FLAC collection that's already here to see what i'm talking about

Also, you should mention what the bitrate of the files are (320 kbps CBR, V0 VBR, etc)

other than that, not too bad for a first attempt  

Shika hit the main points:

1) Bit rates: best place for em is in the "Compression" heading, just put a slash and put the bitrate there

2) Adding both singles. The redundancy is fine when dealing with new tracks, in my opinion.

Since "snow is falling" has nothing to do with Madoka, the regular edition of Magia could be left out... There's a special edition for this anime after all.

Also, there's a special drama CD that was presented to people who bought vol.1, 2 and 3 of Madoka, called "Puella Magi no Ochakai" (Magical Girl's Tea Party, or something like that)

true, but some of us are more OCD than others  

There, requested a swap and edited the description. Too bad I couldn't find official info regarding release date and Catalog Nr. for "Mahou Shoujo-tachi no Ochakai". If anybody could point me in the right direction or just post them her, I'll gladly update it again.

Looks like that talk CD was released in the first volume of the BD/DVD as a special bonus, too.

http://www.madoka-magica.com/bddvd/index.html#vol01
(scroll to the bottom)

So you can probably use the same Cat. No. and date as the Vol.1 Special CD.

I finally found complete scans for Special CD 4. I don't know if your allowed to change a release of a group, but anyway if you want to include them you can get them here: MU link

Thanks for that.
I'd think that in a situation like this, it would be acceptable to change the original release.
I'll put in a swap request and see how it goes.

Is this not missing OST 2 and 3?

its got ost 2 (BD4 bonus) but the next ost won't be out till next month

First of all, I'm not exactly sure of the criteria for "complete" soundtrack so please excuse me if I say something stupid.

I was wondering why this version of the torrent is not being released yet.
Seems like the FLAC version is already complete so are we not able to convert to MP3 from that?
I'd prefer to have a lossy version for storage crisis I'm having right now but if that won't happen any time soon, then I guess I'll have to do that myself.

Any progress on this offer uploader?

So i was like, now that i just finished watching this anime i need the OST..and i logged in..and this was on top of the browse list..hoho xD

Any chance the torrent will be updated with the Kalafina disc that .FLAC version has?

Probably not. I originally had it included in the torrent but removed it on mod request, as it doesn't add any series relevant songs.