Saki (DVD) [ReinWeiss, Underwater-Mahjong]  

what are you talking about? ofcourse this is anime -.-

I was joking because an anime can't be filmed with cameras HD or SD. There are special softs , manual work and experience  involved. (Only )Almost anything except cameras.

PS C apeta is excepted- half is real filming.

It is uncensored though?  Is C grade also uncensored?  I would think this is better not because of quality but because it has uncut content  should count when grading too, but thats just my  opinion.

This is a DVD release, so it's as uncensored as it comes. but there are still scenes of steam in front of important parts in bath scenes and stuff like that. DVD and Blu-ray's are allways as uncensored as possible for that show.

Yeah I think so too that means compared to the censored C grade up top Saki [Underwater-Mahjong] [h.264] [480p]    this D grade is as uncut as its going to get right? So wondering why this is not considered a C grade too since its uncensored and most people prefer to see uncensored than slightly better quality cut up versions. I typically download better grades without checking and its why I ended up downloading both versions  thanks a lot guys lol -.-

Those are NOT grades. That's why.
Slot D is a staff approved exception. This release has worse subs and video quality, and it is only here because it is uncensored.

I think its about time BakaBT have a rating system like IMDB to let users know what we think of the anime, typically its not 100% review but if we rate anime  on scale of 1-10  we get the jist of decent to great anime if you see them with 6-10 than a 1-5 thats how I can tell a movie is decent 99% of the time IMDB are right IV loved every movie that has decent reviews, so I would like bakaBT to have this feature it would be great, thats just my opinion that is. Thanks for clearing the slot system for me.

Actually I prefer not to have system like that. cause then people might not watche anime's and movies that has a low rating, even though they might actually really enjoy it. people should watch themselves, then make a opinion for themselves. not force their opinion on others choices. Why should BakaBT add a system like that anyway, when there already exists a system like that on AniDB?

That's what the IMDB review system is though, its based on the people not the actual anime itself, lets face it there's going to be tons of anime even more than what you and I can download or watch with a system like that it would thin out the best of the best,  nobody has time to watch every anime or even and especially (video games) thats ever been released, the hours would go above average age lol but to pick the better ones out to watch is what the quick easy review vote system is, I don't have enough life span for all the movies ever made, I'm glad IMDB review system exists. I don't think people would dismiss an anime just for review, there's screen shots and talks about it, but would stop people always saying in the post is this any good? or is this good to watch?  look at the tags and review and make your own choice.

well as I said, why should BakaBT have a system like that, when there already is one on AniDB? And there is alot of Anime that is not even present on BakaBT because of licensing rules, that are listed on AniDB. So why not just use AniDB to find Anime from ratings? there's no point for BakaBT to add a system like that as well.

I'm confused. It looks like you both want user reviews like MAL/AniDB/A-P have, but also don't think people should be giving reviews.
If the problem is people asking 'is this good?', they won't stop if BakaBT adds a rating system, and I can imagine a lot more arguing about whether a show was good or bad. If you really think it's a problem you could bug uploaders about putting AniDB ratings in their descriptions.

Actually I don't want ratings or reviews. Just saying if someone wants it, there already is alot of sites with it, like AniDB. So no point in BakaBT adding it =)

Beyond that, trying to add in ratings/reviews of the show would just confuse the issue. The primary focus of BBT is sorting through the different versions/presentations of the shows (ie:the various fansubs). That discussion gets complicated enough without adding on another layer of discussion. As every entry here has a link to AniDB at least, and usually MAL and others as well; leave the show quality discussions to the review specific sites rather than water down, or overly complicate, the discussion going on here.

oh dear god...

I want to see more of this please bring in Season 2 this is just a good story to me and to me quality dousn't matter

NICE   I've been looking for this

shout to the Uploader    THANKS

Since I can't help it even if the BD release is not that satisfactory for others, I am trying to work on it myself.

Here's the link to my workstation: http://goo.gl/yMqBL

I just finished doing my own release of Saki and Saki Picture Drama DVD, so if you want to check it out, it's on nyaa torrent #412401.
Feel free to offer it to bakabt, too^^